Greg and everyone else, the one I was thinking of is now archived and closed for comments, alas. It was started by Herdy (several of us were sitting around in Harford County and thought of that Lovelight) on 9/29/07. Lisa owned that song...Lisapen!
Last post in the thread is by Blythe on 5/21/17 as part of a 10th anniversary revival appreciation. There are some good people in there!
And there is a link to the original review in that thread too. FWIW, I will try to attach it.